Is the Mystery Man In Kat Stickler’s TikTok Videos John Mayer? Dating Rumors, Explained

By George Garcia 10/16/2025

Kat Stickler may have just given fans a major clue about her love life.

The 30-year-old content creator was recently spotted on a date with a mystery man — and TikTok users quickly wondered: could it be John Mayer?

In a video shared by Stickler on September 28, she was seen at an outdoor restaurant wearing a sheer black top layered over a black bra, digging through a black leather purse. The clip was captioned, “Oh no don’t worry I got it,” showing a man across the table — though only his chin and torso were visible.

The video took a hilarious twist when Stickler pulled a small brown dog out of her bag instead of her wallet. She captioned the moment, “No I know,” setting it to Kelly Clarkson’s classic “Breakaway.” Fans quickly turned their attention to her companion, noting his black polo and slightly greying goatee.

“So this is John Mayer,” one viewer wrote, while another commented, “John Mayer — damn girl. I just heard the tea.” The dog gag also sparked amusement. “You could have given me 1k guesses and NONE of them would have been a purse dog,” one user remarked. Another added, “He really thought for a second she was worried about the bill,” followed by laughing emojis.

Jason Tartick and Kat Stickler Split ‘Amicably’ After 6 Months of Dating

Not everyone was convinced the man was the Gravity singer. “Definitely not John Mayer,” one follower insisted. Another argued, “I don’t think it is. John Mayer doesn’t grow as much chin facial hair and his is darker than this man’s. Also this man does not have a cleft chin like John does.”

Despite the speculation, a source told Us Weekly on Monday that Mayer and Stickler are indeed spending time together. “John sought her out and pursued her,” the insider explained. “Kat just broke up with someone she had been dating for a few months and thought it would be fun to date again, and was interested in John.”

Though their reported romance is still in its early stages, the pair has already been spotted out a couple of times. According to Deuxmoi, they were seen last Friday at a private club in New York City, sitting on the same side of a booth and being “very touchy.” The following night, they were photographed hanging out at the Flyfish Club, further fueling dating rumors.

Life & Style has reached out to both John and Kat’s reps but did not immediately hear back.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *